go with the ipod classic, as i recall it has video too. i don't really know about that other one though. lol
i loved my old dell pocket dj.... sniffle..... so easy to use and not constantly being updated like the ipod
Ipod is the way to go. Everything else is just so unreliable. Have you got your mp3 yet ? If so, which one ?
I suggest you get the cheapest one you can find. Remember your using it to listen to MP3's and not to show off.
the cheapest may not be such a great idea as there are a lot of really cheap really crappy mp3 players out there. it ultimately depends on how much music you listen to. you can get a 1 gig flash for next to nothing, and it still holds 200+ songs.